7 positive discipline techniques that are better than time-outs for toddlers

Raising a toddler is no easy task, but it’s one that’s filled with a kaleidoscope of emotions and unforgettable milestones.

You might find yourself questioning if your discipline techniques are too harsh or not effective enough, and wonder what the right balance really is. Are time-outs really helping your toddler understand their mistakes, or are they just creating more confusion and resentment?

After spending countless hours researching child psychology and experimenting with different discipline strategies with my own toddlers, I’ve compiled a list of 7 positive discipline techniques that work better than time-outs.

If you’re searching for a more constructive way to guide your little one’s behavior, these methods could be the answers you’ve been hoping for.

1. Implementation of the “natural consequences” approach

It’s crucial for toddlers to understand the link between actions and consequences – but this can be a tricky concept for their young minds to grasp. Traditional time-outs often fail to highlight this cause and effect relationship, leaving children confused rather than enlightened.

The “natural consequences” method, however, provides a clear and direct connection. For instance, if your toddler refuses to eat their meal, the natural consequence is that they will feel hungry later. Instead of enforcing an unrelated punishment like a time-out, allow them to experience the result of their actions.

This method teaches toddlers that their decisions have direct impacts, offering a valuable lesson in responsibility and decision-making. It’s important, of course, to only allow natural consequences when it’s safe and appropriate – we’re talking about missing dessert rather than something that could cause harm or distress.

With time and consistency, your toddler will begin to understand that their actions shape their world, leading them to make better choices in the future.

2. The embrace of the power of “do-overs”

In the world of adults, we often wish for a chance to do things over. Surprisingly, this concept can be a powerful discipline tool for toddlers as well.

At first glance, it might seem counterintuitive – doesn’t giving them a ‘do-over’ simply let them off the hook for their misbehavior? This isn’t the case when done right.

Rather than sending your toddler into a time-out after a meltdown or a misstep, try offering them a chance to rectify their actions. Ask them to think about what they could have done differently and guide them through the process of doing so.

By promoting ‘do-overs’, you’re nurturing self-reflection and problem-solving skills in your little one. You’re not solely focusing on punishment; you’re assisting them in learning how to handle situations better in the future.

This approach fosters improvement and builds their confidence and resilience, preparing them for life’s inevitable challenges. Discipline isn’t correcting bad behavior – it’s teaching good behavior and fostering growth.

3. The utilization of redirection’s magic

Dealing with a toddler’s tantrum can feel like trying to tame a mini tornado. In these turbulent moments, time-outs can seem like the easiest solution. But what if there was a more effective way?

Meet redirection – the art of shifting your toddler’s attention from a negative behavior to a positive or neutral activity.

When your child throws toys in frustration, redirect their energy towards a constructive task like building a toy tower or drawing a picture, instead of sending them to the corner.

This redirection diffuses the immediate situation while providing an opportunity for your little one to engage in a more beneficial activity. It’s not just ignoring the misbehavior; it’s teaching them a better way to express their feelings or cope with frustration.

Over time, this technique helps toddlers learn self-control and offers them healthier outlets for their energy and emotions. It’s a win-win situation where discipline seamlessly blends with learning and development.

4. The exploration of the world through “guided choices”

Did you know that the average toddler hears the word ‘no’ over 400 times a day? Imagine being told ‘no’ to almost everything you wanted to do or explore – it’s enough to frustrate anyone, let alone a curious toddler.

To counter this, the “guided choices” technique can be a game-changer.

Provide your toddler with two appropriate choices that you’re content with, rather than repeatedly saying ‘no’. In response to playing with water inside the house, offer them the option of coloring a picture or playing with their water toys in the bath later.

Giving your toddler guided choices not only reduces their frustration but also empowers them by allowing them to have some control over their actions. It can prevent power struggles and temper tantrums, making it a more peaceful alternative to time-outs.

This approach fosters decision-making skills and autonomy in your little one, leading them to become more confident and responsible as they grow. It’s an effective way of setting boundaries while still nurturing their curiosity and independence.

5. The power of “time-in” instead of time-out

Let’s be honest, parenting can be messy and challenging. It’s full of beautiful moments, yes, but it also comes with its fair share of tantrums, tears, and resistance. In these moments of chaos, it might feel natural to resort to a time-out, a brief period of isolation to help your toddler calm down.

But here’s the thing – toddlers are just beginning to navigate the world and their emotions. They need guidance, not isolation.

Enter the concept of “time-in”. In place of sending your toddler into a solitary time-out, you sit with them, offering comfort and reassurance. You talk about what happened, how they felt, and how they could handle things differently next time.

This strategy is far from easy. It requires patience, empathy, and sometimes, biting back your own frustration. But it’s worth it. Time-in strengthens your bond with your child and teaches them emotional intelligence – the ability to understand and manage their feelings.

By choosing time-in over time-out, you’re sending a powerful message to your toddler: “Even when you mess up, I’m here for you.” And isn’t that what we all need to hear sometimes?

6. The surprising effectiveness of “ignoring”

When your toddler is acting out, your instinctual reaction might be to immediately address the behavior. After all, isn’t that what discipline is about? But what if I told you that sometimes, the best response is no response at all?

I’m not suggesting that we should ignore our toddlers when they’re in distress or danger. But when it comes to minor misbehaviors that are just attempts at seeking attention – like whining or throwing a non-dangerous object – turning a blind eye can sometimes be the most effective strategy.

Why? Because by reacting, we might unknowingly reinforce the behavior by giving them the attention they’re seeking. By ignoring it, we’re sending a subtle message that such behavior won’t get them what they want.

Once your toddler realizes their actions aren’t yielding the desired response, they’ll likely stop and try something else. At this point, you can provide positive reinforcement for their good behavior.

It feels odd to do nothing in response to misbehavior, but remember – disciplining effectively isn’t about reacting harshly but teaching wisely. This technique requires understanding of your child’s motives, but it can be a powerful tool in your parenting arsenal.

7. The underestimated value of “positive reinforcement”

In the whirlwind of toddlerhood, it’s easy to focus on what your little one is doing wrong. But what about the things they’re doing right?

Often, we underestimate the power of positive reinforcement. This technique involves acknowledging and praising your toddler when they behave well or make good decisions.

If they share their toys with a sibling or manage to calm themselves down after a bout of frustration, take a moment to appreciate their actions. A simple “I’m proud of you for sharing your toys” or “You did a great job calming yourself down” can go a long way.

Positive reinforcement encourages good behavior far more effectively than punishment discourages bad behavior. It boosts your toddler’s self-esteem, motivates them to continue behaving well, and strengthens your bond with them.

Understanding the philosophy behind positive discipline

While the techniques we’ve discussed so far are practical and actionable, it’s equally important to understand the philosophy that underpins positive discipline. This understanding can transform not only how you approach discipline but also how you view your relationship with your toddler.

At its core, positive discipline is about teaching, not punishing. It’s about guiding your toddler towards better behavior, not just correcting their missteps. It’s a long-term approach that focuses on building skills and values that will serve your child well into adulthood – things like empathy, responsibility, self-control, and problem-solving.

Positive discipline also recognizes that bad behavior in toddlers is often a sign of unmet needs or undeveloped skills. A toddler who throws tantrums might be struggling with emotional regulation. A toddler who refuses to share might not yet understand the concept of empathy. By identifying and addressing these underlying issues, you can help your toddler grow and develop in meaningful ways.

Perhaps most importantly, positive discipline is respect and connection. It’s treating your toddler as an individual with their own feelings and needs. It’s building a relationship based on trust and understanding, where your toddler feels safe to make mistakes and learn from them.

Remember, every child is unique and what works for one might not work for another. It’s crucial to be patient, flexible, and willing to adapt your approach as needed. There will be challenging days – days when positive discipline feels anything but easy. But stick with it. The rewards – a strong parent-child relationship, a respectful and empathetic child, less stress and conflict in your home – are well worth the effort.

Ultimately, positive discipline isn’t just a set of techniques – it’s a mindset, an approach, a way of relating to your child that respects their individuality and nurtures their growth. And at the end of the day, isn’t that what parenting is all about?



Hello! I’m Emmarose, your guide and fellow traveler on the sometimes bumpy, often beautiful road of parenting, here at "Careful Parents." With a master’s degree in social work tucked under my belt, years as a life counselor, and my own hands-on experience raising a pre-teen who’s as witty as she is wise, and a newborn who’s convinced sleep is for the weak, I’ve navigated the complex landscape of parenting with its highs and lows. My journey’s been packed with learning curves—like decoding my daughter’s silent language (it’s all in the eyes) and mastering the art of doing practically anything with one hand while cradling a baby in the other. Balancing professional life with being a mom has been less about finding a perfect equilibrium and more about embracing the chaos with grace—and a healthy dose of humor. Indeed, I wholeheartedly embrace a philosophy of gentle parenting, yet with a solid backbone. It's all about setting boundaries with a soft touch, leading the way with a heart full of empathy, and holding a firm belief that mistakes are merely stepping stones to learning. Moreover, I'm deeply convinced that it's through sharing our stories that we carve out our common ground, teaching us the invaluable lesson that, in our parenting journeys, we're never truly alone—whether we're navigating through the tough times or celebrating the victories. "Careful Parents" is built as a haven for us to exchange these stories, advice, and moments of “Oh, I’ve been there too.” Whether you’re wrestling with the bedtime routine, figuring out screen time, or exploring ways to foster your child's growth, this is your space. Let’s journey together with a mix of confidence and curiosity, embracing parenting with all its imperfections and joys. Welcome to "Careful Parents"—where real talk meets real solutions in parenting.

Related articles

Most read articles

Scroll to Top